Have we learnt our lesson or not?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/73e6c/73e6c2a587daefdb84a525bee681814d27993692" alt=""
Malta’s latest performance in Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index is not just a statistic—it is a warning shot across our nation’s bow. Scoring a mere 46 out of 100, Malta has, for the first time since its debut on the index in 2012, fallen below the pass mark. Only Hungary and Bulgaria—two countries long burdened by institutional challenges—record worse figures in the European Union. This isn’t merely a numerical decline; it is an ominous sign that the very foundations of our governance are crumbling.
The score reflects more than just public sentiment; it is a mirror held up to a state in decay. A nation once praised for its robust financial systems is now synonymous with a breakdown in the rule of law. High-profile corruption scandals, notably those involving former Prime Minister Joseph Muscat and his cohorts, have dragged Malta’s reputation through the mud. The charges against Muscat, alongside those levied against former ministers Chris Fearne, Edward Scicluna, and Konrad Mizzi in connection with the contentious hospitals’ magisterial inquiries, serve as stark evidence of a system that has lost its moral compass.
What is perhaps most disquieting is the government’s response—or more aptly, its lack thereof. Instead of acknowledging the deep-seated issues that have led to this historic low, the Cabinet has chosen a path of further subterfuge. On the very day that Transparency International’s report was unveiled, a contentious debate ignited in Parliament over proposed legal amendments designed to restrict magisterial inquiries. These reforms, purportedly aimed at streamlining administrative processes, are in reality a blatant attempt to shield those in power from accountability. They represent a dangerous move to suffocate any genuine investigation into corruption, thereby entrenching an already pervasive culture of impunity.
Esteemed voices from our legal community have spoken out against this draconian measure. Former Chief Justice Silvio Camilleri warned that the bill would “only serve to shield politicians and their persons of trust from investigation,” effectively stripping citizens of the one tool left to uncover wrongdoing. Law professor Kevin Aquilina condemned the proposal as the “fatal torpedoing of the rule of law,” a sentiment echoed by non-partisan organizations and legal bodies alike. Their unanimous opposition underscores the gravity of the situation: instead of addressing corruption head-on, the government appears intent on deepening the crisis.
In this era of rapid global scrutiny, Malta’s international reputation is at stake. A tarnished corruption index not only hampers our ability to attract honest investment but also undermines public trust—a trust that is essential for any functioning democracy. Our nation now teeters on the brink, hurtling toward a precipice from which recovery will be increasingly difficult with each passing day.
Unless there is an immediate and sincere commitment to reform—one that prioritizes transparency, accountability, and the empowerment of civil society—Malta risks becoming a cautionary tale of institutional decay. The government must reverse course, engage in open dialogue with independent institutions, and restore the public’s faith in our democratic processes. Otherwise, as the numbers starkly reveal, we are all in danger of sliding further into a state of irrevocable corruption.
Worse still, these developments come on the heels of our grey-listing by the Financial Action Task Force—a grim episode that should have served as a wake-up call to reform and accountability. Yet, it appears that we have not learned the lesson. Rather than using this moment of international censure to recalibrate our course, the government seems intent on deepening the very practices that led to our isolation in global financial circles. The same complacency that allowed us to be branded as an untrustworthy financial jurisdiction now manifests in our historic collapse on the corruption index.